The Hypocrisy of Respectful Disagreement — and the Scarcity of Genuine “Respect” in the World
Yet people insist that there can be such a thing as that.
Apart from the not inconsiderable reasons that they don’t know the meanings of simple words, why do so many insist on that?
Simply put, they don’t want to give up their disagreement while at the same time not admitting that they are being disrespectful — while, perhaps, determinedly overlooking the disrespect with which they are being treated for the sake of avoiding confrontation.
The pretension of respectful disagreement also enables them to overlook the reality that the “respect” of which we hear so much overwhelmingly derives from sources other than genuine esteem for those upon whom respect is bestowed. “The essence of any hierarchy is retaliation” Samuel Shem wrote in The House of God, and so does it go with the “respect for authority” incessantly propounded by so many as the highest of virtues — respect far, far more likely than anything else to be a matter of tribute extorted by the more-powerful from the less-powerful in a manner that, like so much else we take for granted, gives the lie to all our talk of freedom, equality, individual dignity and the rest.
It also reminds us that what respect is supposed to mean in many minds is a rare thing indeed. After all, respectfulness as something other than an outward show of deference to another out of fear of a blow requires humility, patience, self-restraint on our part. It means admitting that perhaps, just perhaps, another person knows better than we do (as in “I respect your knowledge” or “I respect your judgment”) — or that even if we think we really do know better we have no right to dispute their decision (as in “I respect your privacy”). It means that because of this we listen rather than speak, and resign our right to a say.
That said, now may be a good time to ask yourself honestly just how many people in your life who have actually displayed such qualities, as against how many loudmouthed idiots who think they know best about all things and insist that everyone hear what they have to say, all the time, on everything, regardless of whether they want to or not, no matter what, commonly inflicting on those around them not only their insufferable disrespect but what may be their even more insufferable stupidity. If there is even one person in your life who genuinely has these qualities you can count yourself lucky — and I dare say, owe them at least a measure of genuine respect for having those qualities.
Originally published at https://raritania.blogspot.com.
